Reviewer Ratings Summary

Ottilie Miller: 9/10
Mohammed Hussain: 10/10
Stefan Richer: 7/10

Average Rating: 8.7/10

Track Reception

Most Popular Tracks:

ST. PERCY (3 mentions as favourite)
NO HALO (2 mentions as favourite)

Other Favorites:

BOY BYE, GINGER (Ottilie)
DEARLY DEPARTED (Mohammed)

Least Popular Tracks:

I BEEN BORN AGAIN (Ottilie's worst)
VICTOR ROBERTS (Mohammed's worst)
LOVE ME FOR LIFE (Stefan's worst)

Key Observations

Strengths

Strong opening sequence - First three tracks particularly praised
ST. PERCY emerges as a standout favourite across all reviewers
NO HALO also receives consistent acclaim

Criticisms

Quality inconsistency throughout the album
Weaker middle/latter sections after strong opening
Mixed reception for various individual tracks

Overall Assessment

This album demonstrates strong songcraft with universal praise for certain tracks like "ST. PERCY" and "NO HALO." However, reviewers note a decline in quality after an impressive opening trilogy, suggesting inconsistent execution across the full tracklist. Despite this unevenness, the high average rating indicates the strongest material significantly outweighs the weaker moments.